Re: [alygator] Chamonix 03.10.16 fatality
I don’t know much about W/S BASE – just never developed interest in these flying body bags – but I did know Ratmir personally and while I cannot say that we were super-close, this tragedy resonates with me and members of my family who knew him personally as well. Therefore I would like to contribute to this thread. Here is something that I feel could be important in trying to understand what happened.
This is my rough translation of a social media post Ratmir wrote on September 18, 2016:
Ratmir_via_vk.com wrote:
“…Flying over the rocky river. By the way, I do not recommend to make such flights without special training. Overall right now, the mood amongst BASE jumpers in Chamonix is uneasy. During my most recent trip here, three month ago, we would get up to jump as if it was a celebration. Now everything has changed, while I was away, many famous BASE jumpers have died.
Just as in the past, the valley gets jumped, you can meet 10-15 people on exit at any given time. In general, people have different mindsets, but overall, the collective mood is lacking the fun it was full of in the past. One of my local mates is really upset. He lost four friends just this season, two of which died in front of his eyes. Once I met David Reader’s parents in the landing zone, he was a wind-tunnel world champion and he died recently while proximity-flying in Chamonix.
These cases and the fact that many of my friends have stopped flying low proximity lines
makes me think about what development path I should take from this point onwards and whether those low flights actually make sense. And here are the answers I arrived at:
1. First of all, you get maximum emotional hit on your first flight, the second one is less emotionally charged. Third and fourth flights give away almost no emotions, you perform like a machine;
2. Secondly, it is no longer cool or fashionable. Approximately 10-15 years ago it was considered cool amongst a certain cast of BASE jumpers to open really low, get hit with adrenalin by those low openings – I know because I did it a few times myself. But those times are long gone, nobody opens low any more because it makes no sense, the risk is too great and it pays no dividends. I think that low proximity will follow suite, I believe that in 3-5 years there will be very few people flying that low and people would be looking back to our time saying: can you believe people were flying so low back then and thought it was cool?
3. Rules of the game. When you are flying at 250km/h at just 2-3 meters above the terrain, it is difficult for you to see all of the obstacles, you are tunnel-visioned, you have to know the line off by heart, and if you come across an obstacle which you have not considered, you would either not see it at all or would not be able to react to it. Here is another case – if you are flying next to a cliff face, you could miscalculate side wind at this particular height because the wind up on the exit point and down at the LZ could be null but at that exact spot up on the face there is a right hander blowing you into the rock face while you are carving at that point you understand that you cannot easily alter your angle of attack. I came across all these challenges in the field, I studied the rules of the game , ever-expanding my list of bullet points. And the more challenging the jump, the more rules you need to be aware of. While you are playing the game fault-free, the jumps are not dangerous, but as soon as you make a mistake, the game turns to Russian Roulette – maybe nothing will happen of it and you will keep on flying but if you get a live round in the chamber you will crash and die or will suffer serious injuries.
4. Where to now – there are several disciplines which allow for safe jumping, for chasing new experiences and new highs. For example, there are the starts – you can work on how far you can fly away within the first 200m, a great sporting challenge. Elements of acrobatics – back-flying, corkscrew, 360 – all of these maneuvers can be carried across into BASE jumping, can be performed at safe altitude and can be a lot of fun. Flocking, when you are flying as close as possible to each other without hugging the terrain is totally mind blowing , everyone enjoys these.
Flyby – a close flight past something, like the Ingush Towers¹, for example, this is, in principle, quite safe – you just pick a point and fly past it.
And so this is the point of safe jumping – playing by the rules, following the rules and trying not to make mistakes. So these are the thoughts that popped up after I achieved what I planned six years ago. #baseguru #aviasales #adidasoutdoor #phoenixfly…”
¹msk: a jump that Ratmir was very proud of:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GCqjX9xx8qE
It should also be noted that Ratmir had a bit of “
Russian Jeb Corliss” reputation amongst the Russian BASE community. Probably because he was in the media a lot. And probably because he was taking active steps in trying to commercialise, slash – monetise his hobby slash sport.
His commercial activities in the sport included teaching FJC (which caused some controversy as he was taking FJC students to cliffs in Crimea and Ton Sai) as well as selling his videos.
Ratmir has recently sold the rights to a number of his W/S flight videos to international media networks. Further to that, he struck a deal with a discount airline fare website to carry their logos on his W/S wings and on his rig. As I understand, he was flying this new gear with sponsors’ logos during his last Chamonix trip.
He was very current and has flown technical lines rather confidently (to my non-W/S eye at least):
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KALrgtERp9g Personal opinion: it could be argued that Ratmir was working up towards certain professional skill level for a number of years, taking lessons and tuition from skilled, internationally recognised proxy W/S flyers. He took his time and took baby steps, stretching his W/S BASE learning curve over a 6 year period. As evident from his post, however, once he reached his skill level milestones, he felt doubt. It could be because he felt the upper bound of his skill/ability. Could be something else. We will never know. What we do know is that after writing the above post in late September, he returned to Chamonix in October for more.