Re: [robibird] Flying dagger?
robibird wrote:
Robin,
Why are you starting your answer in a polite way saying you respect both guys for what they did, while you have no honest clue about what they did, nor do you really care?
There is no need to be fake polite, it is much more honest and fair to write without adding sweet words..
Robi, there's an old saying in the USA that the word ASSUME makes an ASS of U and ME.
I was not being fake polite. I meant what I said and one thing I said was that I have not yet met Markus and Mikki, not that I don't know what they have done. I know about Mikki's organizational accomplishments and wisdom from this forum, and know of Markus's achievements through Mikki's comments and those of others.
And yes, I actually do care what they've done and said so in the post above! So for you to
assume otherwise, especially in the face of facts to the contrary in the very post you condemn.... well, 'nuff said about that.
Bottom line: It is precisely
because they are such accomplished, senior and respected members of the community that I take issue with their adolescent chest-thumping about what and how they pursue BASE jumping is so superior to what Jeb does. It is beneath them to act like they did about what Jeb and Iiro and Frank accomplished with that event, that's all.
I also find it ironic how much fake politeness there is about all those dead heroes littering the mountains of Europe after this summer. Every one of them was a capital fellow of great skill and conservative approach and not one of those dead heroes has been subjected to 1 percent of the vitriol being reserved for guys who do things right and stay alive but get a lot of media coverage doing so.
I called Markus and Mikki tedious in their screeds because it's all just a cheap imitation of the crap that was hurled for years at Felix because he too made a good living making jumps that "anybody" can do.
Yeah, right, so what? If anybody can do them, then how come nobody does until Felix or Jeb comes along?
In reply to:
Why are you degrading yourself to this senseless discussion defending Jeb, and doing so by stating facts that have very little to do with the subject? Why you have such a big problem accepting their opinion about the stunt Jeb did?!
Why? Because as I said in that post, what they said is not only tediously pedestrian, it's artless and graceless too, and peeps of their stature and previously demonstrated maturity should know better, that's all.
Moreover, I'm not defending Jeb: Jeb does not need defending. He pulled off a great jump in difficult circumstances under a lot of pressure to perform in less-than-optimal conditions.
All of these effing heroes who are supposedly so much better than Jeb but don't actively seek the glory... great, good for them. I'm one of them, actually. I don't jump much any more but when I do I do it only under optimal conditions and so too do most of those heroes that are all so much better than Jeb.
A quick aside to make a point: I was hired a few years back by an international organization that wanted me to put together a team of jumpers to jump from an object during a big protest action. I flew out to the site and scouted it. The object was about 600 feet high and had a fair number of landing areas but also a bunch of obstacles. It was definitely jumpable -- but it was not
suitable for a public event. As I explained it to the event organizers:
"This is a very jumpable site but very tricky. The wind would have to be zero or blowing within a 10-degree arc at less than 10 mph to make it doable. That would be fine for a private jump in the middle of the night. We could sit there all night waiting for the right conditions -- and if we didn't get them, we'd just climb down and go home. No big deal.
"To do a public event, where people are counting on the jump not just happening but happening at a very specific time, is not feasible because the conditions have to be exactly right within a very narrow range to jump.
"On top of that, there will be pressure to jump in less than optimal conditions, so then you increase the chance that someone will get hurt or killed -- and if someone gets hurt or killed, it blows your whole deal because the focus changes from your message to the carnage incurred while trying to broadcast your message."
Being whuffos, they understood this immediately and didn't let their testosterone jangle their thought processes, so they thanked me for my assessment and cancelled the jump portion of their event.
The point of this story should be clear: All those private hero jumps Markus and the rest of you guys make are fine and fantastic and I respect you all and wish I was doing some of that myself, but doing events is a totally different animal than just going up on the mountain and being responsible for and beholden to no one but yourself.
Seriously, do you really want to dance at the absolute edge of the envelope when you have thousands of people watching in person and tens of millions watching on live TV?
Or do you want to give yourself enough margin to more or less guarantee that if you go you'll still be above room temperature when you shed your gear that day?
Yeah, yeah, I know there are so many "real" heroes who are soooo much better flyers than Jeb and who could eeeasily do that same jump, but you know, how many of them know how to navigate the ways of the world to get to the point where they are the ones who step out of that chopper and do the deed?
So far? Z.E.R.O.
In reply to:
Robin and Jeb, you guys both have a long time in the BASE activity , and I am surprised that both of you feel the need to publicly answer such debate in such a senseless way. Are you really thinking that other active jumpers ( those who really jumping and flying ) will ever have the same response and view to such 'stunt' as wide masses do? the whole "WOW" and "My hero!!" effect?
I won't speak for Jeb, but for my part I briefly answered one rude and apparently clueless individual (leaving wiggle room if he was instead just a brilliantly devious troll), then dropped my hammer on Markus and Mikki because they both oughta know better and be bigger men than they exhibited on this thread.
In reply to:
Are you really sure you can convince them, that that jump was so heavy and terrifying? I hope you know the answer, as if you expected anything different, you guys are being a bit naive.
I did not try to convince them of anything, Robi:
I called them to account for their conduct on this thread.
In reply to:
Funny is that Markus get attacked while he actually congratulates Jeb on his achievement!
Sorry, my brother from another mother, but I call BS on this one -- his "congratulations" were precisely the kind of "fake polite" comment for which you incorrectly castigated me: he used his "congratulations" to frame his artless, graceless and tedious disapproval... disapproval he should have kept as private as all of those hero videos he doesn't show to anybody except his friends. Because as Theodore Roosevelt famously said:
“It is not the critic who counts; not the man who points out how the strong man stumbles, or where the doer of deeds could have done them better. The credit belongs to the man who is actually in the arena, whose face is marred by dust and sweat and blood; who strives valiantly; who errs, who comes short again and again, because there is no effort without error and shortcoming; but who does actually strive to do the deeds; who knows great enthusiasms, the great devotions; who spends himself in a worthy cause; who at the best knows in the end the triumph of high achievement, and who at the worst, if he fails, at least fails while daring greatly, so that his place shall never be with those cold and timid souls who neither know victory nor defeat.”
44