Re: [OLopez] Throw climbing gear attached to pilot chute
OLopez wrote:
If it were me i'd just put the rope in the bottom and the metalware on top and hope for the best. I've dropped gear from quite high up a bunch of times and other than scratches it always survived ok.
Just keep in mind, in most cases you can’t tell if the metalwear strength has been compromised by taking a fall. Carabiners especially, are susceptible to hair-line fractures if they are dropped. These fractures can’t be seen by the naked eye, but can drastically weaken a carabiner. When unloaded, any cracks are most likely closed and not visible. They will open under load, when it is difficult to inspect (like when you are taking a fall on that piece of gear).
One could say using a PC for an upright directional and putting the metalwear on top of a rope will cushion the impact, but it could still potentially cause some damage. The problem isn't that a dropped biner forms a crack and has a lower residual strength when tested immediately, but rather that a significant drop could produce a crack initiation. If the biner is then put back in service where it is cyclically loaded, the initial damage will propagate in fatigue crack growth. Each load cycle grows the crack and lowers the residual strength. Eventually the crack will reach a critical size in which the biner will fail, most likely via ductile tearing. The only way to know if dropped metal gear is fit for use is to test it to its breaking point, which probably would be during taking your next fall on it, while leading a climb, or while doing a tyrolean onto a tower you want to jump
In MHO, throw the rope down if you have to, but jump all the metalwear yourself. Or renew your rack frequently
Just some food for thought.