Re: [RiggerLee] Sangi's View of World Politics
Everybody's right and everybody's wrong. But I'll stick up for Sangi a bit . . .
We'd have to go back a few thousand years to figure out who first hit who over the head with a club to find any blame. And I think when they finally write the book on us Earthlings the conclusion will simply be - it was our nature.
In 1862 President Lincoln said, " We can succeed only by concert. It is not "can any of us imagine better?" but, "can we all do better?" The dogmas of the quiet past, are inadequate to the stormy present."
The blunder old Abe made there was it's not a stormy present. For us humans it's stormy all the time. I used to think God (I'm spiritual, but not religious, so this is a metaphor) made a big mistake by not endowing us with generational learning. Instead we, each of us, must learn the lessons of good and evil for ourselves and do it over and over again. But looked at it another way it's probably for the best. It gives us the opportunity to possibly attain greatness. And it gives us something to get up in the morning for, like I don't know, a better world?
It's easy to believe we are a very fractured society right now. But if there were 24/7 cable news channels in the 1800s even Ben Franklin would have made an ass out of himself. I always thought a saving grace for humans would be if Mars finally did attack. A common off world foe would bring us together like nothing else. But it would also be sad to see that conflict is universal. But the principal of Occam's Razor (the simplest answer is most often the truth) states that it probably is.
So that just means we'll have more work to do. In the meantime we have to deal with these issues in real time and in our real lives. And you have a choice. You can be "Gandhi" like and turn the other cheek. Or you can be "John Wayne" like and try to kill them all. The problem with both ways is we'll never run out of bad guys. So we can't kill them all and we don't have enough cheeks. So it becomes what can you live with it, and more so, what can you die with. I don't believe in a here-after. I'm more of a life's a chemical reaction kind of guy. But if I'm mistaken, and I find myself standing at the Pearly Gates, I've endeavored to get all my excuses lined up and ready to go.
The thing is my excuses are going to be lame. I'm a veteran and I hear all about this PTS stuff and we tell ourselves it's only the weak among us that suffer it. But that can't be true as too many of us have it. So you have to ask yourself why? It's not supposed to be murder when the other guy is wearing a different uniform than you. It's not supposed to be murder when it's a "lawful" war. It's not supposed to be murder when we all become little James Bonds and are duly licensed to kill. If you can live with it than cool. But as the years go by, believe me, it's going to become a bit harder. We have a marvelous ability as humans to come back from most things. You can become un-drunk. You can become un-stupid. You can even become un-hated. But once you take a life you can never come back from that. It's a done deal, or at least as done as we can possibly experience, or imagine. And, after a while, when the bands stop playing, no one carries that burden but you.
"What if they gave a war and nobody came." That was a mantra of my generation. But it was too simplistic. "Make love - not war." Was another good one, but again, I've lived with the same woman for 15 years and the love and war continues." But here's what scares me the most. I think most of us can realize what freedom is to us is also, rightly or wrongly, at least at the rank and file level, freedom to the other guy. It's the classic no-win situation. Unless we stop fighting limited wars. You'd think we would have learned this lesson from past wars like Korea and Vietnam. We could have just obliterated both those countries, but we went with a proportional response. It became the age of the half ass war. Bumped up to today's time I know we are killing villagers in both Iraq and Afghanistan who never even heard of New York.
It's easy to blame the current crop of politicos. And to me, I cringe when I see Marines building schools. We are shock troops. We come in, we kill every enemy we can find, and we go home. I mean we are so fucked up we can't even get war right anymore. And we are backing ourselves into a corner we aren't going to be able to get out of. And that corner, once some politico realizes there's no other way to win, might be to start dropping the A-bombs. I mean think about it. The Jewish-Palestinian problem, Boom over. The Middle East problem, Boom over! The Russians returning to Communism, Boom over! Sounds ridiculous but if we ever get to point when you can't get on bus in Pittsburgh without taking a chance of getting blown up, than watch out, brother.
And that brings us back to Sangi . . .
I'm afflicted, like most old people, even if we didn't want to wind up this way, with a certain disdain for the younger generation. You young-ins just don't get it. You will, but by then you'll be like me and it'll be too late to do anything about it. So thank God for Sangi. He came in here, into this little BASE sanctum and he asked us, "why?" And look at how we all reacted! He challenged us to explain BASE, and now he's challenging us to explain life. Good for him.
I understand the idea, "of we fight for the guy next to us." But I've come to also understand that the guy next to me is every other guy in the world . . .
NickD