Re: [maretus] Starting BASE
In reply to:
Relative wind or not, knowing your motorical skills and being able to work with your body position is a nice skill to have for a base jumper.
Yes, but is it a more important survival skill than an effective track, or good object avoidance canopy skills? I certainly don't think so.
In reply to:
Think this other way, a person like Jeb Corliss for example probably would become a world class freelfyer (he even could be, don't know) very quickly due to his motorical skills and awesome body control he has lerarned through his extensive aerobatics training in BASE.
Remember that we're talking about someone just starting skydiving, with an eye to BASE, here. Do you really think that encouraging them to emphasize throwing aerials as their primary skill set is such a good idea? Wouldn't they be better served to work on survival skills, such as creating object separation and canopy control? Wouldn't it make more sense to focus on the aerobatics
after you've mastered the basics that are necessary for survival?
In reply to:
Is there a skill transfer from BASE to freeflying ? If there is why there wouldn't be the same transfer the other way ?
Why should it matter for a beginner? What is the most important skill or skills for them to focus on? Do you really think that it's aerobatics? Wouldn't they be better served to focus on skills that transfer more directly to the survival skills of BASE?
In my opinion, the priorities for a new BASE jumper are survival skills like stable exits, object avoidance under canopy, and object separation prior to deployment. I believe the skydiving skill sets most likely to transfer best to fundamental survival skills are CRW, Accuracy, and Max Tracking.
I do not believe that aerials are a fundamental survival skill that new jumpers ought to practice before mastering other skills. I do not believe that freeflying has as high a skill transfer for fundamental survival skills.
I am not saying that freeflying develops no transferable skills for BASE jumping. Nor am I saying that mastery of aerials does not increase your chances of survival on any given BASE jump. Just that those things are less important than many other areas, and that beginners ought to be steered toward the skill areas with the maximum return in terms of their survival chances.