Re: [Ken] Free BASE FJC: Oct 29-31
Ken and others,
Let me clarify the "no advertising rule". Once you understand the
purpose of these rules it's not that hard to connect the dots yourself. The difference between a post like the one Ken made (which I will include again later) and Tom's post becomes pretty obvious.
These forums started off with
4 Rules only. As far as I'm concerned those 4 rules still form the bases of the rule system here. We've had to clarify what they mean and interpret them but you'll see that most all the guidelines tie back to these original rules.
I'd like to explain a little why these rules exist and how I came up with them. I've read a little Complexity Theory and this community like all others is a complex system.
Complexity Theory holds that you can create global order (large scale order in complex systems) by applying a few basic rules over, and over again at a local level.
So, these rules were deliberately chosen and I'm hoping (and it seems to be working ok so far) that the dynamics between these four will keep us at the edge of chaos, where complex systems are at their most potent and creative. This is where we'll all learn the most. So the rules are:
1) No personal attacks. None. By taking this out of the loop I'm trying to suppress what seems to be one of the most common human reactions in conflicts and the one that in my experience of the web kills the most online communities.
2) No jokes about or references to pedophilia. None. This is a moral boundary. It basically says: "Almost anything goes, but not everything." Few people will disagree that this is the right place to draw the line. This line is pretty far out though.
3) No advertising in the forums A non-commercial clause, backed by providing a place where people can advertise gear (the classifieds) and events (the calendar) for free. The introduction of money making motives in communities often change the dynamic completely.
The purpose of this rule is to remove that dynamic. 4) Post to the correct forum and stay on topic. A simple rule to prescribe and simple order. Back this with forums (The Bonfire and Speaker's Corner) where people can talk about whatever they want and you actually have an opportunity to cut noise for people to teach and learn. The purpose of this rule is to bring method to the madness.
So that's what I was after. Tom's posts does not even touch on the reason why this rule was created. It breaches it in no manner.
Further, because people have actually split hair about this in the past we've done quite a bit of work to more clearly define "advertising" in the guidelines:
In reply to:
An ad is defined as “a service or product being offered for trade or sale”.
and further on...
In reply to:
You will not advertise or solicit other members to buy, sell or peruse any products or services for that purpose through this discussion forum.
That's pretty clear, and pretty easy to understand.
Look at your post:
In reply to:
New items available from
'Australian B.A.S.E. Association'
1. chick pulling 'T' shirts.
2. hand protecting stubby holders.
Soon to come 'thermal mugs' at:
www.mysitewherewesellstuff.com
BE SAFE
So the short answer is. If you post something and you have direct or hidden money making motive for whatever purpose (there are many noble causes out there), then it is likely to be seen as advertising and treated as such.
We're not going to go overboard , but without any prejudice to the rules as they stand, there's a simple rule of thumb. If your post has a money making motive, you may bump into this rule.
In reply to:
So does this mean I can now advertise the 'free' stubby holders as no money is changing hands for them.
Sure, tell us right here what we need to do to get them for free. Do not try to get us to go over to your site for "more information". Do not try to get us to "peruse any products or services " Just give them away. Can I PM you my snail mail address and you'll send me one for free? Or is there something more to it than that? I commend the fact that you want to put all the money back into the sport, but for obvious reasons we're not going to open the rule up to go down that slippery slope.
There are other ways to get the word out if you truly have a altruistic cause but unfortunately have to go at it through commercial means. Feel free to PM or email me and I'll help where I can.
Again, let's not split hair. The moment you have to actually "try" to convince us it's not advertising, chances are that it is.