Re: [CanuckInUSA] 180s - Risers or Toggles on big canopy and small canopy
RISERS V TOGGLES???
There are arguments both ways and I believe there is no definitive answer. You have to consider many variables prior to making a decision. Some of these variables include:
- jumper experience (student v experienced)
- jumper skill level
- jumper coordination skills
- jumper mental & physical state both at the time of he jump and generally
- type of canopy
- brake setting
- wing loading
- type of toggle
- equipment compatability (i.e. where the toggles are located relative to the jumpers reach)
- weather conditions
- object you are jumping off
- slider up v down
- freefall time
- separation from object during deployment
- flight path and landing options (outs)
- etc etc etc
It is true that you generally get a better response from toggle input as compared to riser input. Especially if your brake settings are too deep. However, it is also true that it is more difficult to consistently grab your toggles on every single occasion. How many video's have you seen where people are fumlbing for their toggles.
It is extremely important to set your gear up properly prior to jumping (esp brake setting).
I teach students to use their risers rather than toggles for the simple reason that they are more likely to get the correct response more often in a high pressure situation (such as a 180 off heading). There is less to think about. The target location for their hands is greater on risers than toggles. There is much less precision required to grab risers over toggles.
I discuss the riser / toggles scenario with each student and explain each of the variables listed above and how to deal with them. I also state to them that once they become more experienced & "dialled in" on canopy control, then they can make the decision that is most appropriate to them.
My personal technique for heading control is along the lines of:
- assess weather conditions prior to each jump.
- determine all possible and probably scenario's for the deploying canopy
- derive a plan of action for each of these scenario's PRIOR TO EXITING (taking into account all variables listed above)
- at each stage of the jump I assess where I am relative to the scenario's I have predetermined and I am already adjusting my plans (i.e. left shoulder dipped low on deployment . . do . . . . and prepare for . . . .
- as the canopy is deploying, my hands are reaching for the general area where my toggles are
- before they get there I am assessing what is happening and what is likely to happen (am I going off heading? which way? etc)
- if things are looking the slightest bit from perfect I am reaching for my risers OR if things are looking good I will grab my toggles.
BTW - I THINK IT IS BETTER TO USE THE "BIG GRAB / STIFFENED / TOGGLES as they are much easier to get the fingers through.
If someone says that everyone should only use risers or toggles, they are not considering all the variables.
Therefore:
- set your equipment up properly (brake settings & easy grab toggles)
- get good instruction
- plan your jump & jump your plan
- be prepared for all scenario's
- use your risers until you gain enough experience, competance, etc.
- make the decision to use toggles once you are satisified that you have considered all factors.
Stay Safe
Have Fun
Good Luck
Tom Begic
p.s. this is just an opinion. I don't claim to have the perfect / correct answer. Just make sure you think before you decide / act.